A "major revision" decision is good news: the editor wants the paper, if you answer well. The response letter is often what decides the next decision. Here is a simple method and a template you can copy.
Before you write
- Read the decision once, then put it aside for a day.
- Copy every comment into one document and number them (Reviewer 1, comment 1…).
- Sort them: easy fixes, analyses to run, points to discuss with co-authors, points you disagree with.
- Share the plan with your co-authors and set a deadline for each task.
The rules of a good response
- Answer every comment, even the small ones, in the same order as the reviewer.
- Thank the reviewer briefly, then go straight to what you changed.
- Say exactly where the change is: page, line, section, figure.
- Quote the new text when the change is short.
- When you disagree, say it politely, with evidence (data, references), and offer a compromise when possible.
- Never argue about the reviewer's competence. Write for the editor, who decides.
- Highlight the changes in the revised manuscript, or provide a version with tracked changes.
Each article follows these steps, with its checks, its files and every version, and its team. Free plan, no card.
Template
Dear Editor, Thank you for the opportunity to revise our manuscript "[title]" ([manuscript number]). We thank the reviewers for their helpful comments. We have answered each of them below, and the changes are highlighted in the revised manuscript. Reviewer 1 Comment 1: [copy the comment] Response: Thank you for this comment. We have [what you did]. See page [x], lines [y–z]: "[new text]". Comment 2: [copy the comment] Response: We respectfully disagree, because [reason, with data or references]. To address the concern, we have [compromise], page [x]. We hope the revised manuscript is now suitable for publication. Yours sincerely, [corresponding author], on behalf of all authors
After resubmission
Keep the response letter, both versions of the manuscript and the reviewers' comments together: a second round of review is common, and the same reviewers will check that you did what you said.
Frequently asked questions
How long do I have to submit a revision?
The editor's letter gives the deadline. If you need more time, ask the editor before the deadline: an extension is usually granted.
What if two reviewers ask for opposite changes?
Choose the option you can best justify, explain the choice to both, and mention the conflict to the editor in the response letter.