A desk rejection often has nothing to do with the science: a missing file, a wrong format or a journal that does not fit. These 20 checks take an hour and save weeks.
The journal
- The topic is within the journal's aims and scope (read it, and look at papers it published recently).
- The article type exists in this journal (original article, short communication, review…), with its word and figure limits.
- You know the fees (publication or open-access charges) and who will pay them.
- The journal is indexed where your institution requires it (for example Scopus or Web of Science).
The manuscript
- The guide for authors is applied: structure, headings, word count, line numbers, page numbers.
- The abstract follows the required format (structured or not) and the word limit.
- Keywords are chosen, ideally different from the words already in the title.
- Every abbreviation is defined at first use.
- Ethics approval, consent and data-availability statements are included when required.
- Funding, conflicts of interest and author contributions are declared.
Each article follows these steps, with its checks, its files and every version, and its team. Free plan, no card.
Figures, tables and references
- Figures are at the required resolution and file format, numbered in the order they are cited.
- Every figure and table is cited in the text, with a self-explanatory legend.
- The reference style matches the journal's, and every reference cited is in the list (and the reverse).
- Supplementary files are named and cited.
Co-authors and files
- All co-authors have read and approved the final version.
- Names, affiliations, ORCID and the corresponding author's email are correct.
- The cover letter says what the paper shows, why it fits the journal, and that it is not under review elsewhere.
- Suggested reviewers (if requested) have no conflict of interest with the authors.
- The final files are the latest versions: check the date and version of each one.
- A copy of everything submitted is kept, with the submission date.
Frequently asked questions
What is a desk rejection?
A rejection by the editor before peer review, often because the paper is out of scope, does not follow the guide for authors, or has an obvious weakness.
Should I suggest reviewers?
If the journal asks, yes: suggest experts in the field who have not worked with you recently and have no conflict of interest. The editor is free to choose others.